Michael Nyman
(Copyright © 1999-2024 Piero Scaruffi | Terms of use )
Decay Music (Obscure, 1976) *
Michael Nyman (Piano, 1981) ***
The Draughtsman's Contract (Charisma, 1982) **
Kiss; Nose-list Song; Water Dances; Images (Editions EG, 1985) ****
A Zed And Two Naughts (That's Entertainment TER-1106, 1985) ***
Drowning By Numbers (Venture, 1987) ***
And Do They Do (That's Entertainment, 1988) **
The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat (Columbia, 1988) ***
La Traversee' De Paris (Criterion, 1989) *
Out Of The Ruins (Silva Screen, 1990) ***
Links:

Summary.
The elegant pulsing scores of Michael Nyman (Britain, 1944), such as Water Dances (1985), Memorial (1985) and The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat (1987), were a post-modernist version of Renaissance music. The orchestral miniatures of the film soundtrack A Zed And Two Naughts (1989) capitalized on retro-catchy melodies and tempos that mocked everything from cabaret to baroque adagios.
This article was originally written for an Italian-language book. If English is your first language and you could translate my old Italian text, please contact me.
Scroll down for recent reviews in english.
Michael Nyman (1944), dopo un periodo trascorso a studiare musica folklorica romena, si guadagna una reputazione come critico musicale (e' lui a coniare il termine "minimalismo" nel 1968), componendo saltuariamente musica assortita per teatro, cinema (nel 1967 ha inizio la collaborazione con Peter Greenaway, su 5 Postcards From Capital Cities), e conservatorio. Per il secondo, in particolare, concepisce 1-100 (1973, variazioni e rallentamenti sul valzer del "Danubio Blu" per solo pianoforte), documentato su Decay Music (Obscure, 1976) con Bell Set No 1 (1971), e Keep It Up Downstairs (1975), che proseguono il progetto di "decadimento" del suono iniziato con Bells (1971) per percussioni metalliche (campane, gong, triangoli, tamtam, eccetera). Assegnati a ogni strumento una nota e un ritmo, il gioco consiste nel rallentare a dismisura le strutture ritmiche predefinite accumulando un numero crescente di volte le unita' ritmiche di cui esse sono composte fino a lasciare soltanto un flusso amorfo di risonanze dalla durata infinita. La "decay music" di Nyman discende dallo "slow motion sound" di Reich, ma acuisce il senso di distacco mediante una progressiva scarnificazione dell'armonia. Rispetto all'ambientale di Eno quella di Nyman e' una musica molto piu' rarefatta ed ermetica.

La transizione verso un'armonia piu' dinamica e trascinante e' gia' evidente nei crescendo marziale di Bird Anthem, nella frenetica marcetta minimalisma di In Re Don Giovanni (quasi una parodia della In C), nel grottesco Waltz (condotto su un tripudio assordante di imitazioni di uccelli), nella demenziale musica da camera di Bird List Song (1981). Sono tutte idee a seguire, incompiuti d'autore, scherzi composti con piglio beffardo e goliarda; ma gettano le basi per una forma musicale in cui non contano complicati equilibrismi armonici, ma semplici contrappunti, cori e crescendo, ovvero tutto l'arsenale del sensazionalismo in musica usato in modo al tempo stesso stereotipico e straniante.

The orchestral Michael Nyman (Piano, 1981) already displays his trademark progressions, especially in Bird Anthem, juxtaposing the circular melodies of some strings and the pounding rhythm of other strings while a large choir leads the repetition, in the cabaret-tish lied Bird List Song, and in In Re Don Giovanni (later renamed Mozart for a single), a fast-paced and comical take on the same form that sounds like it was scored for a marching band. The dissonant Waltz in F for wind instruments seems to belong to another phase. The 21-minute M-Work is Nyman's attempt to stretch his repetitive patterns to the typical duration of a concerto but in order to do so he has to paste together a number of variations that don't quite follow logically. It's an attempt that will not be repeated for a while. The melodramatic pomp of the beginning is also somewhat "un-Nyman-esque", whereas the exuberant polka-like finale would make for a great piece by itself.

The 7" single Michael Nyman (Piano, 1982) contains In Re Don Giovanni and Last But One.

La lunga M-Work (1982) riassume i principi della sua arte: una revisione in senso comico del minimalismo, un uso prevalentemente ritmico dell'orchestra, una scansione marziale degli accordi delle melodie, il ricorso a incalzanti crescendo di sezioni d'archi, una spiccata preferenza per il tempo drammatico della marcia, un'allusione continua a rondo', minuetti, salmi e requiem, un convulso sviluppo tematico, una sovrapposizione caotica di diversi blocchi armonici, la mancanza di una fine in cui culmini la trama del brano. Nel segno del postmoderno piu' metalinguistico, il Wagner del minimalismo erige torri di Babele musicali prendendo spunto dalle colonne sonore del cinema e dalle bande di paese.

(Clicka qua per la versione Italiana)

The Draughtsman's Contract (Charisma, 1982) contains seven fragments of Nyman's soundtrack for the Greenaway film. Queen Of The Night mixes the renaissance-like grace of the strings and the melancholy melodies repeated by the winds. Then the strings rise in a majestic, baroque largo and are joined by a harpsichord for the emphatic finale. The Disposition of the Linen is even more baroque and uptempo, a breezy dance in a salon of mirrors. The minimalist repetition is subtle but induces much more movement than it is evident. The technique is, instead, fairly programmatic in An Eye for Optical Theory and in the longest theme, Bravura in the Face of Grief. Elements of Albinoni's Adagio float inside the shimmering filigree of The Garden Is Becoming a Robe Room (for strings and harpsichord) which eventually bursts into a hymn-like frenzy.

Nyman thus began a career as a major composer, specializing in symphonic tours-de-force with ever more complex ensembles of strings and winds through which he vivisected, decomposed and reassembled the tradition of chamber music from Henry Purcell to Mozart. Peaks of this period were the narcissistic caprices of Images Were Introduced, scored for nine-unit ensemble with vocalist Dagmar Krause engaged in a virtuoso operatic performance, Nose List Song (1985), an accelerating whirlwind of a dance again with Brecht-ian operatic vocals, and especially the Water Dances (1984), perhaps his masterpiece, a fantastic algorithm of melodic progression that borrows from the Penguin Cafè Orchestra's approach to classical music but pushes the boundaries of musical counterpoint and augments it with a grandiloquent breathless finale. These three were collected on The Kiss (Editions EG, 1985).

And Do They Do (1986) is a cycle of four untitled songs. The first one boasts the most propulsive and dynamic crescendo, in which different patterns and groups of instruments alternate at leading the collective bacchanal. The second one is, instead, a gentle elegy. The third and the fourth resume the mad pace of the first one, although with inferior brilliance.

A Zed And Two Naughts (1989) is a soundtrack divided in twelve orchestral miniatures. The melodies are almost always retro-captivating, and the range of moods is disorienting to say the least: Angelfish Decay, L'Escargot and Swan Rot are comic skits, almost accelerated versions of senseless charleston-era dances, whereas Car Crash boasts a dramatic panzer-like tempo and Time Lapse (possibly the standout) is a cubistic rendition an Albinoni adagio scored for robotic orchestra, but no less poignant. The soundtrack keeps shifting style, first indulging in Delft Waltz and then in the sublime pop aria Venus De Milo.

The soundtrack for Greenaway's Drowning By Numbers (1987) is ostensibly a series of variations on Mozart's Sinfonia Concertante, scored for a 20-unit ensemble. Nyman's method was beginning to crystallize: the strings repeat elementary staccato melodic patterns with increasing strength and minimal variations, and then soloists weave moving themes in the vein of the classical adagio. Nyman focused on the juxtaposition of vehement tension (the pummeling repetitive instruments) and tender gravity (the hummable lead melodies).

Drowning By Numbers appropriates elements of renaissance, baroque and romantic music, and casts them in a firmly aseptic, modernist light. (the melancholy adagio of Trysting Fields, the elegant dance of Sheep and Tides, the festive aria of Bees in Trees, the plaintive melody of Drowning by Number 3). Minimalist repetition turns those innocent tributes into harmonic catastrophes: the string-driven progression in staccato of Wheelbarrow Walk is a therapeutic trauma; while incursions in popular music cast a doubt on the gravity of the proceedings (see the grotesque Wedding Tango). The longer suites, such as Drowning by Number 2 and the eight-minute Endgame, mix and balance the postmodernist and the modernist urges.

The chamber opera The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat (1986), scored for soprano, tenor, baritone, harp, piano and string quintet, harks back to the British tradition of chamber operas, but also to Britten's chamber lieder (Your Husband's A Painter), to Broadway show tunes (Pawn To King 4), to Robert Ashley's conversational operas (I Cannot Tell You What's Wrong) and even to baroque music (What's The Time). There are relatively few Nyman-esque progressions (That's Why I'm Here, But What Of The Parietal Regions).

The Cook The Thief (1990) closed the tetralogy of soundtracks for Peter Greenaway. It included the majestic death march of Memorial (1985), another peak of the composer, in which the strings endlessly repeat a Purcell melody and the trumpet turns it into an epic refrain a` la Ennio Morricone. Towards the end a soprano and a saxophone enter the scene, the soprano unleashing long desperate cries and the saxophone joining the funeral procession. The other pieces focus a lot more on the melody than on the process of repetition. Notably, the horns "sing" a sublime melody in Book Depository. The eleven-minute Miserere is a dialogue between a contralto and a choir, with the contralto living in a relatively modern era and the choir stuck in the age of sacred medieval music.

Out Of The Ruins (1989) was instead a choral requiem for the victims of an earthquake, inspired by Gregorian Chants and sacred music of the baroque age. These works clearly displayed a bleaker mood than his early compositions. Nyman had started out by toying with classical structures, but now it seemed like he was trying to deliver meaning and not just form, and that meaning had to do with the human condition.

After the successful collaborations with director Peter Greenaway, particularly in The Draughtsman's Contract (1982), A Zed & Two Noughts (1985), Drowning By Numbers (1988), The Cook, The Thief, His Wife & Her Lover (1989) and Prospero's Books (1991), Michael Nyman became one of the most prestigious composer of film soundtracks: Monsieur Hire (1989), La Traversee' De Paris (Criterion, 1989), Le Mari de la Coiffeuse (1990), Songbook (1992), A La Folie (Virgin, 1994), The Piano (Virgin, 1993), Carrington (Argo, 1995), Diary of Anne Frank (1995), The Ogre (1996), Gattaca (Virgin, 1998), Wonderland (Venture, 1999), Ravenous (EMI, 1999), co-scored with Blur's vocalist Damon Albarn, The End Of The Affair (Venture, 2000), The Claim (2000), Man With a Movie Camera (2000), Subterrain (2001), La Stanza Del Figlio (2001), Luminal (2002), 24 Heures De La Vie d'Une Femme (Maive, 2002), Charged (2003), The Actors (EMI, 2003), and many, many others, of lower and lower quality. He soon became an assembly factory of cliches for film soundtracks. Film Music 1980-2001 (Venture, 2001) is an anthology.

Prospero's Books (1991) alternates between operatic arias, orchestral adagios, and his typical exuberant ascending repetitive-pattern instrumentals (Prospero's Curse, Prospero's Magic, Miranda, History of Sycorax); but this is hardly innovative anymore. It often sounds childish and derivative (of his own style).

The Piano is perhaps the most celebrated of Nyman's soundtracks. It features both orchestral and piano pieces. The orchestral ones range from the nostalgic adagios of To The Edge of the Earth and A Wild And Distant Shore to the moving elegies of The Promise and Lost And Found, with peaks of pathos in the majestic crescendo of Deep Into the Forest and the final apotheosis of Dreams Of A Journey. The piano pieces (the romantic piano sonata of Big My Secret, the rousing piano rigmarole The Heart Asks Pleasure First, the mournful aria of The Sacrifice) are not all that different in mood.

Live (Virgin, 1995) and Live in Concert (Virgin, 1999) show how trivial his performances are.

Nyman has mostly failed to impress in the forms of traditional chamber music. He has composed four string quartets, of which the first is a weak work (inspired by some John Bull variations, it uses a Schoenberg fragment as the building block for its 12 movememts), while the second (1988), in six movements, and the third (1990), in two long movements, recycle themes from previous works (the latter from Out of the Ruins) aiming for the mainstream rather than for groundbreaking solutions. The second movement (fast-paced and intricate) and the playful sixth movement are the highlights of the second quartet, The vigorous second movement of the third quartet is also notable, if nothing else for the weay it fragments and then layers up its languid melody. The fourth (1995), originally a solo violin composition, is by far the most significant: the performer is left free to choose five of the original 12 movements, and arrange them as she pleases. The first three are collected on String Quartets 1-3 (Argo, 1991); the last three are collected on String Quartets Nos. 2-4 (Black Box, 2002). The Suit & The Photograph (EMI, 1998) contains the 12-movement String Quartet 4 (1995) and Three Quartets (1994), which combines a string quartet, a brass quartet and a saxophone quartet in one single piece.

Time Will Pronounce (Argo, 1993) contains three chamber works from 1992: Time Will Pronounce, The Convertibility of Lute Strings, For John Cage. After Extra Time (Virgin, 1996) contains After extra time, The final score, Memorial . These are all mediocre works.

Noises, Sounds and Sweet Airs (Argo, 1994) is the score for an opera-ballet based on Shakespeare's "The Tempest" (again). Taking a Line for a Second Walk (Work Music, 1994) contains the 1986 work for orchestra and the Water Dances (1984). An Eye for a Difference (Tring, 1998) has compositions for the London Saxophonic.

His main compositions of the 1990s were the concertos: the saxophone concerto Where The Bee Dances (1991), the Violin Concerto (2003), etc. Three of them (Harpsichord, Trombone, Double Concerto) appear on Concertos (EMI, 1997). The Concerto for Harpsichord and Strings (1995) is a laborious (and not always successful) work in six movements: the geometric patterns of the first movement achieves a multidimensional frenzy lead to the jubilant Russian-style dance of the second, and the quasi-pop aria of the third leads to the manic pounding of the sixth. The Concerto for Trombone (1995), perhaps the most complex, starts out with a mournful invocation but then plunges into ever more chaotic and hysterical constructs. It finally relaxes a bit when the trombone intones a nostalgic melody, and then, signaled by drum beats, it launches into a last gallop only to stumble into dissonant percussive confusion and decay into barely audible laments. Neither concerto is fully convincing.

The Double Concerto (1997) for cello and saxophone, perhaps the most brilliant and phantasmagoric, is in five movements: a slow crescendo of repetition with the two lead instruments engaging in an almost Middle-Eastern whirlwind while the orchestral mass becomes heavier and heavier, a carefree allegro propelled by a bucolic saxophone refrain, a grandiose if brief baroque dance, a chaotic agonizing lento that eventually radiates tranquillity, and an epic final march worthy of the Celtic jigs.

The Piano Concerto (1993), which recycles music from The Piano, is well documented: The Piano Concerto (Argo, 1994), The Piano Concerto/ On the Fiddle / Prospero's Books (Tring, 1995), The Piano Concerto and other Themes (Las Nuevas Musicas, 1995), The Piano Concerto/ Where the Bee Dances (Naxos, 1998).

He also scored music for a multimedia event based on David King's book The Commissar Vanishes (Venture, 1999).

His operas include Facing Goya (2000), released on Facing Goya (Warner, 2002), and Man and Boy - Dada (2004).

Sangam (Warner, 2003) is a failed attempt to reconcile (improvised) Indian classical music and (composed) Western classical music. The result is mostly background muzak for cocktail party.

The Piano Sings (MN, 2005) offers piano-only versions of some of this film themes.

The Libertine (MN, 2006) is a mediocre film soundtrack.

What is unique about this music database