Intelligence is not Artificial

(These are excerpts from my book "Intelligence is not Artificial")

### Footnote: Neural Networks as Vector Spaces

When a neural network is trained to "learn" some pattern, its neurons get organized in a rather geometric manner. A neural network basically constructs a high-dimensional space in which the distance between two points mirrors the degree of relationship between two objects in the real world. For example, two words that tend to show up together in many sentences will be represented by two points very close to each other. These "points" in high-dimensional spaces are "vectors". This was the discovery made by Tomas Mikolov's team at Google in 2013, using the "skip-gram" method for constructing vector representations of words from analyzing large sets of text, a method now known as "word2vec" ("Distributed Representations of Words and Phrases and their Compositionality", 2013). The same approach can be used to analyze images or speech, and, again, turn a large set into a high-dimensional vector space. Now you can use an old mathematical tool called "vector arithmetic" and perform calculations on these vectors. Mikolov showed that, for example, one can perform this algebraic operation: "vec(king) - vec(man) + vec(woman)" and obtain "vec(queen)". Unfortunately (or luckily), this method ended up revealing embarrassing biases in the texts of our world. For example, in 2016 Tolga Bolukbasi at Boston University used a neural network to calculate "vec(father) - vec(doctor) + vec(mother)". You would expect the answer to be still "doctor" as there are many female doctors, but instead the answer (obvious once you see it) was "nurse": the line from male doctor to female doctor is not a straight one ("Man is to Computer Programmer as Woman is to Homemaker", 2016). As Einstein would put it, the vector space is warped!

Neural networks that are trained only on co-occurrence of words in the past texts of the world tend to amplify the biases of the past. Unfortunately, this bias is then passed on to the many "recommendation engines" that increasingly control people's private lives. The result is, for example, that males will be more likely to be presented an ad advertising a highly-paid Silicon Valley job than females will. Hence the need for "de-biasing" the algorithms used to train neural networks for word embeddings. James Zou's group at Stanford, for example, introduced a post-processing algorithm that removes some of the biases "Multiaccuracy", 2018).

The skip-gram model, just like the bag-of-words model, needs to be trained to minimize a "loss function". The problem is that probabilistic models of language like these are computationally prohibitive because they require the mathematical processing of an entire vocabulary, which consists of tens of thousands of words. Two main "short cuts" were in use: "hierarchical softmax", by Yoshua Bengio's student Frederic Morin at the University of Montreal ("Hierarchical Probabilistic Neural Network Language Model", 2005), and "noise-contrastive estimation", developed by Michael Gutmann and Aapo Hyvarinen at the University of Helsinki ("Noise-contrastive Estimation", 2010). Mikolov used "negative sampling", a simplified variation of noise-contrastive estimation.

For the record, vectors were introduced in the 19th century book "The Barycentric Calculus" (1827), published by August Moebius, the same German mathematician who in 1858 discovered the Moebius strip, and were indirectly popularized by James Maxwell's classic on electromagnetism, "Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism" (1873), and even more by Werner Heisenberg's version of Quantum Mechanics (1925) that used matrix and vector algebras instead of calculus (Erwin Schroedinger's version). It turns out that they seem to be ideal mathematical tools not only for electromagnetic waves and quantum systems but also for brains.

"Never underestimate the power of a small group of people to change the world. In fact, it is the only way it ever has" (Margaret Mead)

Back to the Table of Contents

Purchase "Intelligence is not Artificial")
Back to Cognitive Science | My book on consciousness | My reviews of books | Contact