Piero Scaruffi
(Copyright © 2005 Piero Scaruffi | Terms of use )

Philosophy of Mind
Philosophy of Nature
Links:

Click here for the essays that appeared in my book "Synthesis" (2009)
Synopsis:
  • The mental cannot arise ex nihilo from the non-mental
  • Cognition is pervasive in nature
  • The mental is a property of matter, of all matter
  • Everything has a "mental" aspect, although it is likely that only in the configuration and structure of the human brain that "mental" aspect yields the human form of mental life (consciousness, emotions, the self, etc)
  • Just like electricity and liquidity are macroscopic properties that are caused by microscopic properties of the constituents, so consciousness is a macroscopic property of our brain that is caused by a microscopic "mental" property of its constituents
  • The human mind is the product of the co-evolution of memes, language, tools, emotions and brains.

  • Relativity Theory is about the universe, about the dimensions of existence
  • Quantum Theory is about the human world of objects, about the world of "sizes"
  • Relativistic spacetime is the equivalent of an ocean, and quantum values are the equivalent of the ripples caused by an object moving through the ocean of spacetime: Relativity is the theory about the ocean, and Quantum Theory is the theory about the ripples
  • Quantum Theory describes the ripples caused in spacetime by energy-matter in motion
  • Einstein's equations describe how spacetime warps because of matter. Schroedinger's equations describe the ripples caused by such matter.
  • Spacetime is the continuum that energy-matter interacts with
  • Quantum values are the results of measuring the ripples caused by that interaction
  • Spacetime has an atomic structure, just like matter. There are indivisible units of spacetime. This also removes once for all Zero's paradoxes.

  • Imitation, not innovation, is the fundamental social instinct
  • Ignorance, not knowledge, is the natural state of humans
  • Western democracy ("one person one vote") tends to become the rule of the mediocre (if they are free, they want to be ignorant)
  • The remedy is a "democracy of the wise": each voter counted proportional to her/his knowledge

  • For thousands of years the human mind has created by imitating nature. Cars have four wheels because mammals have four legs. Planes have two wings because birds have two wings. However, during the 20th century the human race has transitioned into the age of abstraction. Nature is no longer the model. Quantum Theory, Relativity, abstract painting, avantgarde music, the computer, the Internet are not modeled after nature. They represent a new stage of the human mind.

  • Greed is unique to the human species: other animals content themselves with what they need in order to survive. Humans are never satiated. We work even if we already have enough food, clothing and housing. There is basically no end to human needs because the needs of a human being change as previous needs are satisfied, whereas animal needs are always the same. Marketing (the creation of new needs) makes sense only for the human species. Civilizations are the product of this endless quest for more. Greed is the fundamental force that set the human species apart from the other species.

  • Different threads of history: territorial annexation (Rome, Mongols, Arabs, Britain, France), economic domination (Athens, Venice, USA), competent isolationism (Tang/Song China)
  • New civilizations are born "at the edge of the world":
    • When the world was Egypt and Mesopotamia, the new civilization was born in Greece
    • Greece and Achaemenian Persia: Rome
    • Rome and Sassanid Persia: Arabs
    • Arabs and Song China: Mongols
    • France and Holy Roman Empire: Britain
    • British Empire and Germany: USA

  • Humans have always been puzzled by change: everything changes all the time (matter), but something does not change (form)
  • Human civilization is about things that do not change: building immortal things (whether a piece of furniture or a building or a road)
  • Unlike natural environments, human civilization requires continuous maintenance
  • Ultimate products of human civilization, that defy change: books, photographs, films

  • The human mind grasps more easily the concept of infinite than the concept of finite. We had no problem accepting that the universe is infinite, but now we have trouble accepting that it is finite. We ask "if it is finite, what is beyond it?", i.e. we want to make it infinite.

  • The mystical experience corresponds (roughly) to a paralysis of the neocortex. Both hallucinogenic drugs and collective hysteria cause a paralysis of the neocortex.
  • The neocortex is the evolutionarily newer part of the brain, that is (mostly) unique to humans. The older part of the human brain is very similar to the brains of the other mammals, and the very old part of the human brain is still basically the same brain of reptiles.
  • Thus a human brain whose neocortex is disabled behaves largely like the brain of a mammal.
  • If that "is" the mystical experience, then the mystical experience must be widespread among animals, and, since there is no neocortex to balance it with a rational experience, it is fundamentally the "only" state of their mind.
  • Basically, not only do cats "experience god", but they do it all the time. They constantly live in an hallucinated present.
  • The effect of the neocortex is to make sense of the mystical experience like it makes sense of everything else that happens. Thus humans create very complex rituals and religions, which other animals don't.

  • Metabolizing information is the real issue of the digital age. The speed that we can absorb information is much faster than the speed at which we can process it. The Internet browser (the person who browses websites on the Internet) is a massive consumer but a poor producer. The Internet browser mostly lets the random access to websites (frequently driven by search-engine rankings) shape her/his understanding of the world, i.e. her/his psyche. As a whole, society's psychology is shaped by the websites we access and the interactions that follow. We are approaching the day when we will simply download our life from the Internet just like today we download songs and films.
  • When the USA opened new land to colonization, the goal was to get as large a piece of land as possible, and then make it lucrative. In the digital age the goal is to get as high a page-ranking as possible, and then make it lucrative. The race for geographical territory has been replaced by a race for attention.
  • We still have to find meaning in the physical and biological sciences. The biological sciences present the human body as an information-processing system (e.g. the brain). But where does knowledge come from? The biological sciences present the species as an information-processing system (DNA). But where does purpose come from? The physical sciences present the universe as a colossal machine. But where does our consciousness come from? The digital sciences present the noosphere as a colossal web of interconnected pieces of information. But it's ultimate function so far has been to create a new market for modern capitalism. The sciences are still unable to bridge the semantic gap. In fact, that gap is increasing.

People quote me as "atheist" but i could claim to be an atheist (someone who doesn't believe in gods) only if there was a definition of what a "god" is. The universe or the big bang or general relativity or many other scientific entities often qualify for definitions that i see here and there, in which case i am not an atheist: yes, something created this universe, and something propels it, etc. So my "atheism" depends on your definition of "god". My religion is that religions are mostly false. Religions were created by humans and in some cases i have simple explanations for their beliefs. The Jewish religion is simply the story of the Jews (a rather violent story). Their god is simply some ancient leader/king who promised them a land (in this life, on this planet) if they obey him. The Christian religion was shaped by the Roman Empire, so it became a mess. Whatever Jesus originally said was watered down and distorted in the first few centuries when the Christians had to survive in the Roman Empire, and so Christians now worship the Old Testament despite the fact that it is obviously not a Christian book (but it conveniently condones violence, something that the Roman emperors obviously wanted). The Islamic religion is a distortion of the Jewish and Christian religions for the purpose of creating a world empire. The god of the Jews, the god of Jesus and Allah have little in common: they are different gods for different people just like Zeus and Apollo, or Isis and Maat, were different gods for different people Buddhism wasn't even supposed to be a religion (Buddha had no god). What we call "Hinduism" is just a bunch of more or less unrelated mythologies. The human mind is programmed to think symbolically, and therefore creates symbols and metaphors all the time, and some of them become legends, and the legends became laws when adopted by the ruling class. Is there something useful in religious books? Mostly for psychologists and anthropologists who study how the human mind creates ridiculous legends and irrational beliefs.
People ask me what have been the most influential books on my thinking, but actually these two funny stories have had the most impact. I am not sure about the details but they roughly go like this. The Lone Ranger and Tonto are camping in the desert. In the middle of the night Tonto wakes up the Lone Ranger and asks him: "Look up: what do you see?" The Lone Ranger replies: "I see millions of stars". Tonto asks: "And what does that tell you?" The Lone Ranger ponders the question for a while and then replies: "Astronomically speaking, it tells me there are millions of galaxies and potentially billions of planets. Astrologically speaking, it tells me that Saturn is in Leo. Time wise, it appears to be approximately a quarter past three in the morning. Theologically, the Lord is all-powerful and we are small and insignificant. Meteorologically, it seems we will have a beautiful day tomorrow. Why, what does it tell you, Tonto?" Tonto rolls his eyes and says: "You are dumber than buffalo crap: it means that someone has stolen the roof of our tent!" Lesson learned: too many to explain here. But definitely something for all scientists and scholars to think about.

The other one originated from a Stanford philosopher, John Perry: "I once followed a trail of sugar on a supermarket floor, pushing my cart down the aisle on one side of a tall counter and back the aisle on the other, seeking the shopper with the torn sack to tell him he was making a mess. With each trip around the counter, the trail became thicker. But I seemed unable to catch up. Finally it dawned on me. I was the shopper I was trying to catch." Lesson learned: it's basically a variation on Pogo's "I have seen the enemy and it's us". Whenever they talk about their problems (whether it's Italians, white US citizens, Muslims, black Americans, Africans, Latin-Americans, ...), i tell people to first look into the mirror.

(Copyright © 2005 Piero Scaruffi | Terms of use )